Can You Donate Privately-Held Company Shares?

Donating private company shares to charitable organizations has gained traction as a tax-efficient and impactful way to support philanthropic causes. High-profile donations have brought attention to the scale and impact of such contributions. Opting for stock donations over cash can maximize the benefits for both the donor’s tax situation and the charity’s financial health. By contributing appreciated shares directly to a charity, donors can potentially avoid capital gains taxes while claiming a deduction for the full fair market value of the shares.

These examples demonstrate the growing trend of philanthropic giving through private company shares, as donors seek to optimize their charitable impact while navigating complex tax regulations.

​

Eligibility of Private Shares for Donation: Understanding the Criteria

Private company shares, also known as closely held or restricted stock, differ from publicly traded stocks in terms of liquidity and transferability. To be eligible for donation, private shares must meet specific criteria to ensure the charity can effectively receive and manage these assets. As implied by Endaoment’s asset acceptance policies, the charity must have the capability to handle illiquid assets, such as private shares, and comply with applicable legal and accounting requirements.

When considering a donation of private company shares, it is crucial to assess the charity’s ability to accept and manage these assets. This includes evaluating the organization’s experience with non-cash donations, its capacity to accurately value the shares, and its understanding of the legal and tax implications associated with holding and disposing of private stock. Charities equipped to handle illiquid assets are better positioned to maximize the value of private share donations and ensure compliance with relevant regulations.

​

Tax Implications of Donating Private Shares: Maximizing Benefits

Donating private shares held for more than one year can offer significant tax advantages. By contributing these shares directly to a charity, donors can potentially avoid capital gains taxes on the appreciated value while claiming a tax deduction for the fair market value of the shares at the time of donation. This approach allows donors to maximize their philanthropic impact while minimizing their tax liability.

To establish the fair market value of private shares for tax purposes, donors must obtain a qualified appraisal. Although not explicitly outlined in Endaoment’s documentation, this requirement is a common practice in the context of IRS regulations for non-cash charitable contributions. A qualified appraisal, conducted by a professional with expertise in valuing private company shares, provides a defensible estimate of the shares’ worth and ensures compliance with tax reporting requirements.

​

Process and Considerations for Donating Private Shares to Charity

Donating private shares to a charity or a donor-advised fund (DAF) involves several steps and considerations. The donation process typically includes:

1. Engaging with the charity or DAF sponsor, such as Endaoment, to discuss the intention to donate private shares and ensure their ability to accept and manage these assets.
2. Obtaining a qualified appraisal to determine the fair market value of the shares for tax reporting purposes.
3. Completing the necessary paperwork, such as a stock transfer agreement, to facilitate the transfer of ownership from the donor to the charity or DAF.
4. Collaborating with the charity or DAF sponsor to ensure timely acknowledgment of the donation and accurate reporting to the IRS.

Throughout the donation process, it is essential to consult with tax and legal professionals who specialize in charitable giving and private company stock. These experts can guide donors through the complexities associated with transferring private shares, ensuring compliance with IRS guidelines and avoiding unintended consequences. They can also advise on matters such as board approval or specific shareholder agreements that may be required before transferring private shares, as these assets are subject to different regulations than publicly traded stocks.