What is the Difference Between a Donor-Advised Fund and a Charitable Trust?

Philanthropic individuals often grapple with the choice between donor-advised funds (DAFs) and charitable trusts when planning their giving strategies. Both vehicles offer unique advantages for charitable giving, but they differ significantly in structure, control, and tax implications.

This article explores the key distinctions between DAFs and charitable trusts to help donors make informed decisions about their philanthropic endeavors.

​

Defining Donor-Advised Funds and Charitable Trusts

A donor-advised fund is a philanthropic vehicle established at a public charity. It allows donors to make a charitable contribution, receive an immediate tax benefit, and then recommend grants from the fund over time. Endaoment, for instance, offers DAFs that accept a wide range of assets, including cryptocurrency and traditional securities.

Charitable trusts, on the other hand, are legal entities created to hold and manage assets for charitable purposes. There are two main types: charitable remainder trusts (CRTs) and charitable lead trusts (CLTs). Each type offers different benefits and structures for donors and beneficiaries.

​

Ownership and Control: Who Holds the Reins?

One of the fundamental differences between DAFs and charitable trusts lies in the ownership and control of assets. With a donor-advised fund at Endaoment, donors relinquish ownership of the contributed assets to the sponsoring organization. While donors retain the privilege to recommend grants, the ultimate decision-making authority rests with Endaoment.

Charitable trusts offer a different ownership structure. The trust itself owns the assets, but the donor may retain significant control depending on the type of trust established. For example, in a charitable remainder trust, the donor or designated beneficiaries receive income from the trust for a specified period, with the remainder going to charity.

​

Tax Implications: Immediate Benefits vs. Long-Term Strategies

The tax treatment of donor-advised funds and charitable trusts varies significantly. Contributions to a DAF through Endaoment provide an immediate tax deduction for the full fair market value of the donated assets. This feature is particularly advantageous for donors with appreciated assets, as they can avoid capital gains taxes while maximizing their charitable deduction.

Charitable trusts offer more complex tax benefits. Charitable remainder trusts provide an immediate partial tax deduction based on the present value of the future gift to charity. Charitable lead trusts, conversely, may offer gift and estate tax benefits, as they can reduce the taxable value of a donor’s estate.

​

Flexibility and Ease of Use: Streamlined Giving vs. Customized Planning

Donor-advised funds, especially those offered by Endaoment, pride themselves on flexibility and ease of use. Donors can contribute a variety of assets, including cash, securities, and cryptocurrency. Grant recommendations can be made at any time through a user-friendly online platform, allowing for responsive and dynamic giving.

Charitable trusts, while offering customization, typically involve more complex setup and maintenance. They require drafting a trust agreement, often with the help of legal professionals. Ongoing administration may include annual tax filings and more involved record-keeping. However, this complexity allows for highly tailored giving strategies that align with specific estate planning goals.

​

Regulatory Environment: Public Charity vs. Private Entity

The regulatory landscape for donor-advised funds and charitable trusts differs substantially. DAFs operate under the umbrella of public charities like Endaoment, subjecting them to specific IRS regulations. These rules ensure transparency and prevent self-dealing, but generally offer a lighter regulatory touch compared to private foundations.

Charitable trusts, as separate legal entities, face more stringent regulatory requirements. They must file annual tax returns (Form 990-PF for private foundations or Form 5227 for split-interest trusts) and may be subject to public disclosure requirements. This increased oversight can provide additional accountability but also demands more administrative attention from donors or their advisors.

​

Suitability for Different Donors: Matching Vehicle to Vision

The choice between a donor-advised fund and a charitable trust often depends on the donor’s specific circumstances and philanthropic goals. DAFs, like those offered by Endaoment, are well-suited for donors who:

1. Seek immediate tax benefits
2. Desire a simple, low-cost giving solution
3. Want to involve family members in philanthropy without the complexities of a private foundation
4. Wish to give anonymously

Charitable trusts may be more appropriate for donors who:

1. Have substantial assets and complex estate planning needs
2. Want to provide income to non-charitable beneficiaries while ultimately supporting charitable causes
3. Aim to reduce estate taxes through sophisticated giving strategies
4. Desire maximum control over the investment and distribution of charitable assets

Whether opting for the streamlined approach of a donor-advised fund or the customized structure of a charitable trust, the key lies in matching the giving vehicle to the donor’s unique vision for impact. Understanding these differences empowers donors to select the philanthropic vehicle that best aligns with their financial situation, charitable objectives, and legacy planning goals.